Creep (2004) review

Creep posterDirector: Christopher Smith

Starring: Franka Potente, Paul Rattray, Kelly Scott, Sean Harris

“It sounds to me like some vigilante train driver got a wee bit carried away. The way I see it, you should be thanking the man, not running away from him.” (Jimmy, Creep)

The London Underground can be a bit pish sometimes. I’ve lived here for nine years and feel I am qualified to say this.

In fact, I’m writing this review on a Northern Line train just now and there’s an upended Chicken Cottage box on the ground, its delicious greasy goodness spilled all over the floor as an offering to the Tube gods.

But much as it leaves to be desired, it’s fair to say it could still be a hell of a lot worse. I’m talking “home to a hideously deformed hermit who kills passengers” worse.

Just in case you can’t imagine that premise, Creep is helpfully here to show us exactly what it would be like in unflinching detail.

Meet Kate. She’s German. But it’s not all bad news! Actually, it more or less is: she’s pretty self-centered. She’s the sort of person who doesn’t just politely decline homeless people when they beg for money, she has a visible disdain for them.

Look at that bloody sneer on her face. She'd kick your face in as soon as look at you. Or something
Look at that bloody sneer on her face. She’d kick your face in as soon as look at you

Kate’s something of a party-goer, and while she’s at one of her usual soirees a chum informs her that George ‘no, I’m not actually in this film’ Clooney is attending another function elsewhere in London.

Eager to become Mrs Clooney (though clearly now it’s a bit late for that), Kate decides to head across London to this other party to try to find and seduce the C-Dawg.

Unable to get a taxi, Kate resorts to taking the Tube, heading into Charing Cross station in an attempt to catch the last train. She falls asleep and misses it, and when she awakens she realises she’s been left in the locked station all alone.

Feeling foolish, she goes back to sleep, wakes up the next morning and sheepishly goes home. The end.

"I'm no expert on the Tube but I think I've made a wrong turn somewhere. Is this the Victoria Line? Ah wait, I can hear a train coming, that might be it OH CHRIST"
“I’m no expert on the Tube but I think I’ve made a wrong turn somewhere. Is this the Victoria Line? Ah wait, I can hear a train coming, that might be it OH CHRIST”

Okay, not really. While trying to find a way out of the station, Kate hears another train pulling into the platform. Confused, she boards it, even though the last train is gone.

Good news: Kate’s work colleague Guy is also on the train. Bad news: Guy is significantly more rapey than most men are supposed to be (i.e. not at all).

Good news: Guy is dragged out of the train by an unseen killer who brutally attacks him. Bad news: That means there’s an unseen killer brutally attacking people.

Clue: It's that guy
Clue: It’s probably that guy

Thankfully, Kate manages to escape and finds Jimmy and Mandy, two homeless folks living in a secret compartment inside the station. Oh, and Jimmy’s Scottish, because homelessness. Sigh.

Offering to pay them (oh, the irony!) to help her, Jimmy reluctantly agrees to help, leaving Mandy behind and thereby causing her to involuntarily break the horror film rule of sticking together to avoid becoming the killer’s next target.

Without spoiling too much, Kate, Jimmy, Mandy and another chap Kate later meets called George all find themselves stuck in an underground and sewer system inhabited by Craig, the aforementioned deformed killer.

Can Kate escape Craig and do what many tourists have failed to do over the years: make her way out of Charing Cross station with both her life and sanity intact?

"I'm sorry, there weren't any Evening Standards left. You'll have to make do with a Stylist"
“I’m sorry, there weren’t any Evening Standards left. You’ll have to make do with a Stylist”

Creep is a fantastic looking film. Shot partly on location on a disused platform on the Jubilee Line and partly at Three Mill Studios in London, it does a great job of making things look as bleak as possible. There’s barely a location in this film you’d fancy visiting for any real length of time.

Craig is also a brilliant movie monster. Disgusting to look at and genuinely brutal (I defy you to watch one absolutely horrendous scene in particular involving Mandy without doing so through your fingers), he fufils the film’s title by being creepy and then some.

So much emphasis is put on villains looking scary in modern horror films but Craig is also also one of the better-sounding monsters of recent years too. His tendency to belt out horrendous, inhuman screams and screeches is properly effective stuff.

"I'm dreadfully sorry, madam. This is my first day as a make-up artist"
“I’m dreadfully sorry, madam. This is my first day as a make-up artist, you see”

However, Creep suffers due to one simple fact: Kate’s a cow.

It’s rare that a horror film makes its protagonist a nasty person, and there’s an obvious reason for that: if their death is a real possibility, you’re going to have to make the audience care enough about them that they don’t want to see that happen.

On the very rare occasion the hero is an arrogant prick, this is either addressed by them being a lovable rogue (Ash in Army Of Darkness) or them seeing the error of their ways as the film progresses and eventually becoming good.

By introducing our ‘heroine’ as a homeless-hating wannabe starfucker however, then showing her continued reluctance to team up with the homeless couple later on, it’s hard to get fully behind her because you can’t shake off the feeling that when she’s no longer in danger she’ll go back to her old self-centered ways.

Yeah, that light means you probably want to get out of the way mate
Yeah, that light means you probably want to get out of the way mate

It’s a shame, because other than this fairly major flaw, Creep is effective. It’s atmospheric, has a brilliant monster and does a good job further enforcing my belief that the Tube is evil.

Sadly, what makes it merely ‘good’ instead of ‘great’ is a protagonist who’s too difficult to emotionally invest in. And, as ever, if you don’t invest much into it, you can’t get much out of it.


Creep is only available on DVD – here’s the UK one and here’s the US one. It currently isn’t available anywhere for streaming.


2 thoughts on “Creep (2004) review

  1. are you kidding me? this film was really underrated to me, and kate felt a lot more reltable than an “average” compassionate empathetic mid-west girl. she was the way most people are when they shed their sociable facade, self-centered and yes a bit of a bitch but not too much. a perfect character to me and i was rooting for her the entire film.

Leave a Reply